Skip to content
Education Niche
Menu
  • Education News
  • Health Education
  • Education Kindergarten
  • High School Education
  • Education Definition
Menu
Meaning Must Come First During Instruction Reading (Opinion)

Meaning Must Come First During Instruction Reading (Opinion)

Posted on 29/06/2023

To the Editor:

I believe EdWeek’s article “What is Background Knowledge, and How Does It Fit With Reading Science?” (January 30, 2023) is problematic. The “science of reading” inspired by the National Reading Panel was never scientifically tested for efficacy by experts before being presented as the only way to teach reading.

Try reading this. The topic is “reading”:

Ti is pssbleoi to rdea wtouthi snudign otu wdros. I will jtsu dmsteontrade it.

Instead of decoding the sentence, the brain has to search for the message. And, to find the message, the brain has to compare minimal phonetic information with all the knowledge and language you’ve acquired to find something meaningful.

Those who promote decoding as a necessary basic reading skill ignore research cited in a 2006 article showing 1 percent of all 5 to 6 year olds. those who could read by the time they entered preschool, kindergarten, or 1st grade did so without ever being formally taught to decode. My grandson is one of them. He is a 3rd grader and reading at grade 5/6 level.

Readers I struggled with overcame their reading problems even though I never asked them to decode a single word. Using the method of my mentor Dee Tadlock, I help students ages 7 to 57 become readers by placing first meaning and guiding them to know how to use phonetic information strategically to anticipate language in stories (what you did above to read random sentences).

My new readers (ages 5 and 6) aren’t learning to read—a—word—at—once—with a—pause—pause—between—every—word. There is NO meaning in a single word. Language is what we use to express meaning. Means, therefore, must come first.

Rhonda Stone
Parent Lawyer & Reading Tutor/Coach
Co-authorRead Right! (McGraw-Hill, 2005)
Shelton, Wash.

How to Send

Education Week Opinion welcomes submissions from various perspectives within the K-12 education community. Regardless of your role in education, we want to hear from you.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Understanding the Benefits of Lifestyle Medicine
  • How to Stay Healthy During Flu Season
  • Exploring the Dangers of Smoking and Vaping
  • The Connection Between Sports and Mental Health
  • Understanding the Gut-Brain Connection: How Your Belly Affects Your Mood
  • Contact Us
  • Disclosure Policy
  • Sitemap

"high school education business definition of education definition of education pdf definitions of education educational meaning education definition oxford education definition webster estate fashion health health education in schools high school educational games high school education online high school education on resume high school in usa high school or secondary school high school usa wiki how long is kindergarten how many years in kindergarten how many years is kindergarten improvement india is kindergarten free is secondary education high school jewellery jewelry kindergarten german latest leisure market newest online pre secondary education primary and secondary education secondary education secondary school technology travel trends types of education updates visual art terms what is education when did kindergarten become mandatory

©2025 Education Niche | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme

WhatsApp us